Does 9PM Rebel smell like Afnan Supremacy Collector's Edition OR Hawas Black?

I have a $10 coupon which I am trying to redeem and looking into buying 9PM Rebel.

Does 9PM Rebel smell like Afnan Supremacy Collector's Edition OR Hawas Black? I already have those (collector's edition is one of my favourites) and wondering if 9PM Rebel is redundant?